No MAGA Mandate on Public Education as Voters Reject Vouchers, Culture Wars

The other day, I overheard it at the gas station. The day before, I saw it when I opened my local news app. And the day before that, it was on my local TV station, between segments on the weather and the Cleveland Browns. Everywhere I look, MAGA allies are claiming that the results of the past election give them a mandate to enact their most extreme policies. 

But across the country, when it comes to education, voters rejected those policies loudly and firmly. As the founder of Red Wine & Blue, a community of over 600,000 diverse suburban women, I hear from women all the time who don’t want right-wing extremist groups coming into their school districts to impose their vision of so-called parents’ rights. The vast majority of moms believe in America’s public schools, want to work with their children’s teachers to make education better and are sick of a vocal minority wasting time and resources on culture war chaos. 

But I don’t just say this because it’s what I see in my group chats and hear in conversations at the bus stop. Of the common-sense candidates — those standing up to attacks on history lessons about race and age-appropriate sex ed — who were supported by my organization in school board races across the country, 69% won. And in some states, that figure is even higher: 78% of our 45 candidates won in 15 Michigan school districts, and 86% of our 14 candidates won in six Virginia districts — an especially gratifying result given that Virginia became ground zero for the uproar over so-called Critical Race Theory in 2021.

Meanwhile, in North Carolina, Mo Green, a Democrat and former superintendent of Guilford County Schools, won the statewide race for superintendent of public instruction over homeschooler Michele Morrow. Morrow was a Republican Moms for Liberty candidate who has described public schools as “indoctrination centers” and urged people not to send their children to them; called for the assassination of national leaders; and demanded military intervention to keep then-President Donald Trump in power on Jan. 6, 2021. Trump may have won the presidential race in North Carolina, but Morrow’s slogan, “Make America’s Schools Great Again,” clearly didn’t resonate with the majority of voters who want to build up their public schools, not tear them down.

It’s true that different parents and families have different values and concerns — and that’s okay. If there’s a book you don’t want your kids to read, then don’t let them read it. I believe in providing students with accurate, age-appropriate sex education, but I also believe in allowing parents to opt their kids out if they alone want to have those conversations. But I don’t think one parent should be able to take those opportunities away from everyone else’s kids. American public schools should be, at their core, places where all students should feel supported and safe. And while extremists have come in from outside communities to gain power, divide and control people, most voters want none of it. 

If you zoom out and examine other election results, you see similar trends. Republicans spent at least $215 million on political ads attacking the trans community — including trans children who attend public schools — on issues ranging from sports to health care. But there is no evidence that these ads swayed voters at the ballot box. In fact, an October poll found that a majority of likely voters (including a plurality of Independents, by a 23-point margin) thought they were “meanspirited and out of hand.” Likewise, a post-election poll of voters in eight Senate battleground states found that those who saw the ads found them “intensely off-putting” and that they failed to impact candidate support. 

In four states — including three that voted for Trump — voters rejected Republican priorities for education. Ballot measures to expand voucher programs, which shift money from public to private schools, failed in Colorado, Kentucky, Nebraska. In Florida (the home of Moms for Liberty), voters defeated a state constitutional amendment to make school board elections partisan.

MAGA politicians will ignore these rejections at their own peril. Many parents remain concerned about their students and the state of the public schools. And when I sit down and talk to them, we almost always realize that we have far more in common than what separates us. We don’t want a loud minority telling us how to raise our children. We don’t want books about Anne Frank or Martin Luther King Jr. to be banned. We certainly don’t want kids to be bullied just because of who they are. It’s time to tune out the claims of MAGA mandates and get to work with teachers and administrators for the good of all students.

Get stories like these delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter